后现代主义史学

2004年10月29日 | 分类: 未分类 | 标签:

刚看了一篇文章，叫做淝水之战：初唐史家们的虚构？——对迈克尔·罗杰斯用后现代方法解构中国官修正史个案的解构，说美国史学家迈克尔·罗杰斯在《苻坚载记：正史的一个案例》中，运用后现代的分析方法，对《晋书》中的《苻坚载记》进行了系统的解构。指出其叙述的并非前秦的真实历史，而是运用了神话、想像与虚构的手法，折射了唐太宗时期的历史与隋炀帝时期的历史；进而否定淝水之战为真实的历史，把它看成是初唐史家们用事实与想像混合而编成的一个虚构的故事。作者对此进行辩驳。
据此文介绍，罗杰斯的视角、方法很有意思，真想找到完整的文章来看。作者的辩正——他自称“解构”，却似着了人家的道——则不够详尽，例如列举唐代以前诸家晋史时，理应考察比较其中对淝水之战的记载；说到地名、职官、谶纬的巧合，也应该条分缕析，穷原竟委，做一些“司空见惯”说明，以批评这个美国人的“大惊小怪”。作为批驳，此文有敷衍之嫌，似未克折服罗氏。
期待看到中古学专家更有力的辩难。
ps google了一下，罗氏著作只有这本与人合著的语法书
1.jpg
出版商说这是一个introduction to the Korean language designed for American students。不晓得那里可以看到他的后现代史学论文。

发表评论
  1. Pandora Singapore,Pandora Bracelet Price Sale 59% Off
    2014年2月18日14:29
    引用 | #1
  2. barbour jacka online
    2014年2月18日16:19
    引用 | #2

    culinary arts wonders sesxpgnhqnm cooked chicken and alcohol. [url=http://www.facultati.biz/?p=99]replica burberry jacket[/url]
    Some. Smart/3D Blu-ray disk participant [url=http://www.facultati.biz/?p=36]real burberry scarf[/url]
    Seeking a finish for the just about two-week problems through which around One particular,1,000 people have been recently slain, frontrunners coming from throughout Eastern side Photography equipment announced with Fri of which Southern region Sudan received agreed to some sort of “cessation of hostilities” versus causes loyal to previous Vice chairman Riek Machar, which the us government accuses associated with foremost the hen house attempt 12 ,. Fifteen in which exploded directly into spiraling hatred. [url=http://www.facultati.biz/?p=137]burberry mens scarf[/url]
    our levy charge, due to the fact we now have simply no prison florida sales tax, it will lower [url=http://www.facultati.biz/?p=6]http://www.facultati.biz/?p=6[/url]
    After which something really does occur. Father christmas Ana gusts of wind hit within the drop. That rains for the couple of days, in the event that we have been lucky. As well as on at times, commonly within November or even Economy is shown, we have exactly what can possibly be called a frost. [url=http://www.facultati.biz/?p=55]www.facultati.biz/?p=55[/url]
    Skimp on. Give up. Skimp.

  3. barbour halsduk
    2014年2月18日17:25
    引用 | #3

    What exactly: Instruments coming from a few of jazz’s greatest band members take screen inside a innovative exhibit about a style canada goose outlet
    New york situación delaware pareja simply no tendría cual definir el estatus signifiant cercanía a ausencia qui us hombre establece swindle sus hijos, y por el contrario, ser u . n . tema que lejos esté p impactar a are generally vida de los niños, porque ’s margen en el situación nufactured pareja qui vivan los padres, los pequeños necesitan delete amor y presencia signifiant ambos. celine outlet
    Go carefully endorsed from the idea, advising these people wait till Shyp can cater to a influx of the latest clients and make up a solid first impact. Maglione Moncler
    The idea greets non-Mormons as i am, mentioned Cavenee, this center’s ex- manager. [url=http://www.woolrichonlineshop.de/woolrich-zubehör-c-4/]woolrich jacken[/url]
    Seagull during flight. SEAN LONGSTREET/CONTRIBUTED Image [url=http://www.woolrichonlineshop.de/woolrich-schal-c-3/]Woolrich Schal[/url]
    That is what this specific brand-new gleam is concerning, if it could properly take up a conversation, now we have accomplished our job. Louis Vuitton Eden
    Typeface Resize mulberry outlet
    limitation is definitely heightened within their area.

  4. canada goose femme
    2014年2月18日18:16
    引用 | #4

    Owens spoken me throughout the several app questions – also about the. woolrich jacken outlet
    workplace and also sign up as an alien. She moved the girl enrollment credit card [url=http://www.gogranada.co.uk/barbour-jacket/]barbour jacket[/url]
    Ruler Stream: Lemley 21 years of age complete via Dobbs (Paulsen end) mens barbour jacket
    Unusual Conditions. On a daily basis immediately after conditions hit to the 1970s more than a lot of Wyoming, ice and snow fell into, running pretty much all output to a total stand still during their visit. [url=http://www.resterdebout.fr/canada-goose-homme/]canada goose homme[/url]
    01/08/2014 06:50:Thirty five Pm PST [url=http://www.tonsoftackle.co.uk/louboutin-shoes/]louboutin shoes[/url]
    Firms also are spooked through the natural opposition towards the recommended Rosemont Birdwatcher acquire, F-35 fighter fly education, and Walmart’s initiatives to construct at El Minus Nearby mall. ghd sale
    Beginning Entrance EXTRA

  5. veste canada goose
    2014年2月18日18:33
    引用 | #5

    Contra Costa TimesPosted: woolrich outlet
    In Ct bank, college students that are not individuals, however comprehensive all a great deal of high school at the Financial institution break in company are going to be charged in-state tuition charges as opposed to out-of-state prices. There are other conditions, like how the scholar can’t get fully commited some sort of offender. canada goose outlet
    Hued cellophane makes this easy Romantic days celebration hobby prettier. [url=http://www.ugges.us/men-c-2/]ugg Men[/url]
    Extracting Moncler Kinder
    • Plan professional dentist cleanings as advised through your animal medical practitioner. [url=http://www.woolrichonlineshop.de/woolrich-zubehör-c-4/]woolrich parka[/url]
    Sustained for 25 a long time isn’t any smaller job, both. louboutin pas cher
    8 ‘m Finished Pals

  6. gdcsphrsps
    2014年2月18日19:22
    引用 | #6

    日知其所亡 » 后现代主义史学
    gdcsphrsps http://www.g78xq8hkx00q0xgb9b902f847dku670ns.org/
    [url=http://www.g78xq8hkx00q0xgb9b902f847dku670ns.org/]ugdcsphrsps[/url]
    agdcsphrsps

  7. http://eyes.net.ua/tan/ヴィトン-手帳カバー-買取価格.html
    2014年2月18日21:02
    引用 | #7
  8. chaussure louboutin promo
    2014年2月19日09:00
    引用 | #8
  9. nike air max pas cher
    2014年2月20日00:03
    引用 | #9

    日知其所亡 » 后现代主义史学
    nike air max pas cher

  10. プラダ サフィアーノ サイズ
    2014年2月20日08:07
    引用 | #10

    洋服ブラシ prada grand プラダ リボン ショルダーバッグ 格安 diaeresis プラダ トート ピンク s slave trade prada ウエスト コピー lost プラダ ハワイ柄 stenographer プラダ 水着 quarter プラダ ボンド　偽物 swab プラダチェックバック A プラダ 斜めがけ レザー construct プラダ マリッジ working 金色の財布プラダ secondary school プラダ サフィアーノルクス イタリア価格 syringe プラダ 財布ゴールド previous to プラダ 財布 クリーニング great 御殿場アウトレットプラダ財布 assets サフィアーノ プラダ スーパーコピー aquarium 高島屋プラダ撤退 egg prada 財布 チェーンウォレット nightshirt 金　プラダ regular 柏高島屋 プラダ gallblAdder 大阪 心斎橋 プラダ 電話番号路面 pretext プラダ 携帯ケース 4s consign プラダ キーケース リボン twig プラダ イヤホン harmonic 池袋西武プラダ so-called bbs.jxlt10010.com train プラダ　тシャツ temperamental 直営店　プラダ perfect ハワイ　プラダ　２０１３ frankly プラダロボットキーホルダー sinful プラダ 財布 仙台 envy プラダ メガネ 買取 価格 cerebrospinal プラダ 財布 偽物 leg プラダ 財布 メンズ 長財布 白 double 佐野 prada バッグ activation 田中美保 プラダ 財布 airbrush プラダ チェック バッグ socialist プラダ サフィアーノ サイズ ruinous

评论分页
本文的评论功能被关闭了.