“王君”是谁？

2006年4月26日 | 分类: 未分类 | 标签:


新购汪荣祖《史学九章》，略翻一过。本来是想读一遍的；此前看过《史传通说》，印象不错。其书有专章论“槐聚史学”，便先拣这章来看。一看之下，胃口全无。先不论钱氏在史学上的见识究竟如何，只看汪氏不厌其烦翻来覆去引述《管》、《谈》的只言片语，解说、发明则毫无新意，读者不觉昏然入睡矣。这章是看不完的了。
书中钱穆一章，早看过单行论文，批驳不无道理，但着眼都在小处，如因袭梁启超书，引用不查原史资料；而对书中将宋学与清学“打通”、于清季诸人独推举曾国藩等“大结裹”，既不能细析其所以然，也提不出有力的质疑，破不尽，立不起，反而弄得自己很尴尬。
章炳麟一章，专门拈出清代开国秘史，大作表扬。其实，当时考证建州逸史者，不乏名家后劲，如孟、朱、萧、郑、王等人，较诸章氏，创获更大。真要表彰章氏史学，固应择其所论有关先秦史及制度史者，才是知音。
其他几章，介绍西方史学流派，似亦多泛语，少独见。俱不如《史传通说》之深切著明。尤其是第五章——西方史家对中国传统史学的理解与误解，以例证丰富、辨析深刻而言，自然比不上《通说》（此书副题为中西史学之比较），而措辞之精确，行文之流畅，竟也不及。真是奇怪。要知道，《通说》于1988年出版，《九章》则为2002年出版，不过十馀年，才尽学退，真可达到如此的程度？
回头检讨一下读过的汪氏著作。《陈寅恪传》是少作，其失在浅。《郭嵩焘传》，作者寄托太深，对传主揄扬太过，其失在矫。《康章合论》，因译乃师《康有为变法与大同思想研究》，搭个便车，发挥绪馀，未足言著述。《晚清思想史研究》，仍未出其师范围。总结：可观者，只有一部《通说》。
近年又看过几篇汪氏与余英时论战的文章；其实，辩论的都是“八卦”——胡适的婚外情，陈寅恪的晚年心境。双方各执一词，都有道理，是非难定。不过，若论逻辑谨严、行文有致，汪又落了下风。反观余氏近著有关朱子者，取精用宏，别开生面，或有牵强，终是一家之言，必传之作也。当然，强拉二人同列，有点比拟不伦。汪固难望余氏项背。惟汪氏有一事差胜，盖年辈稍後，若奋力搏去，犹可冀老树生花，拉近一点距离。
看了半天，此书只有一个小八卦有点意思，即166页影印的钱锺书致汪荣祖书，中云：
来信所言在沪交往四君，皆旧相识，王君尝化名□作文痛诋拙著，後来则刻意结纳，美国俗语所谓”If you can’t lick ‘em, join ‘em”者是，弟亦虚与委蛇。要之均俗学陋儒，不足当通雅之目。
□，原文写出，但影印件看不清楚（或编者故意？）。
这个“王君”是谁呢？

发表评论
  1. ralph lauren online shop
    2014年1月7日17:35
    引用 | #1

    We attempted checking out your blog using the apple, ipod touch as well as the design doesnt appear to be suitable. May wish to find out about it about WAP and it seems almost all cellular phone layouts aren’t genuinely handling your blog.

  2. uggs rain boots sale
    2014年1月7日17:54
    引用 | #2

    For some reason, There are this kind of difficult time with the much captcha codes. Consequently glad this location doesnt’ make use of it! You could almost never go through all of them!

  3. hjgyjjsjvl
    2014年1月7日18:35
    引用 | #3

    日知其所亡 » “王君”是谁？
    [url=http://www.gw921mwqce2l5amz6e745646mk387zu0s.org/]uhjgyjjsjvl[/url]
    hjgyjjsjvl http://www.gw921mwqce2l5amz6e745646mk387zu0s.org/
    ahjgyjjsjvl

  4. louis vuitton bags
    2014年1月7日18:57
    引用 | #4
  5. babyliss pro straightner
    2014年1月7日19:20
    引用 | #5

    My partner and i can’t trust you didnt speak about JANGO. com, i always enjoy ha, i understand, jango is the greatest and in addition they don’t know it Why not consider shuffleer user friendly chrome ext giving a list of sorte from which to choose and it also trawls by way of weblogs and also websites to find excellent msuic in your case take a look Problem with all of these purchase you pay attention to anything really subway occur to be screwed. Final. fm has recommended us so many independent, beneath senseur performers awesome nevertheless We can never come across whatever else about these artists from internet sites in the list above. Entire services are of help for what these people meant for i really still cannot gathering some of them. Great info.
    babyliss pro straightner

  6. beats by dre
    2014年1月7日19:57
    引用 | #6

    Sam’s, Costco and BJ’s) but you should get a day pass to make sure that they have things you use
    beats by dre

  7. ugg boots chestnut tall
    2014年1月7日20:32
    引用 | #7

    My spouse and i uncertainty there are actually 15 individuals on this state who would have got elected intended for Romney except the point that he hasn’t already unveiled their taxation statements. Now i’m using Romney about this one particular.
    ugg boots chestnut tall

  8. zippy wallet louis vuitton
    2014年1月7日20:37
    引用 | #8

    Zero chief executive ever previously has become inquire to release ten years of back fees. Anyone Leftist good guy Warren Buffett and Obama’s buddy still has an outstanding loan for 2006 back taxes. Where’s the rage from the still left. nIf Romney’s old fees had been incorrect although have already been absorbed in in the past. My six Figures revenue not too long ago Uncle Sam hit myself for a nothing at all $ 111. 18. nWhen you actually play by the adversaries regulations. There are actually not any Regulations. nSo we all placed the rules very first and previous. nQuote inch Saul Alinsky
    zippy wallet louis vuitton

  9. Ugg Classic Cardy
    2014年1月7日20:54
    引用 | #9

    日知其所亡 » “王君”是谁？ Ugg Australia Bailey Button juzhzkn purple bailey bow uggs asbwysa bow boots qazlilc Bailey Button Ugg icsiqibk bailey bow uggs hzorjrwyt Ugg Bailey Bow Tall eqmkmiddw Uggs Sale
    Ugg Classic Cardy

  10. pink bailey bow uggs
    2014年1月8日04:55
    引用 | #10

    The report done in this post (extract below) will be improper.
    pink bailey bow uggs

评论分页
本文的评论功能被关闭了.