朱苏力

2004年11月4日 | 分类: 未分类 | 标签:

干完活，搜得一篇朱苏力对杨念群儒学地域化的近代形态的书评。第一句话，朱氏便开起了玩笑：
本文其实是一只披羊皮的狼或是一只披着狼皮的羊。
杨，谐羊；不仅如此，还念念不忘群居、害怕落单。朱氏作为法学界人士，受邀参加近代史作品（杨著）研讨会，恰好是一条冲进羊群（披羊皮的）狼。明明是狼，却又说自己不过是“披着狼皮的羊”，则是客气话，以为接下来的尖锐批评作点缓冲。都说朱氏文章写得好，洵非虚誉。
具体如何批评，可以看链接。杨氏此书，我在书店翻过，看了几页，便没兴趣了。虽然，按照我的兴趣，这样的书应该买下来。并非我特别不具耐心，实在是他标点的《杨度日记》，很早以前便让我倒了胃口，根本不敢相信他具备研究历史的能力。作为杨度的曾孙，先不说他是否承继（了解？）了家学，只看他满篇的错字、破句，便令读者愤愤不平，脱口说出不肖二字（其书已埋在书柜深处，那天找出来抄录几段给大家看看）
回头再说一句朱评。朱氏自承不懂历史，可你看他末尾这段话：
我倒是想强调费正清模式的一个优点，是他的这一模式，至少其中译（冲击/回应），给人的印象是，回应并非清醒的、有意识的，而是一种机体的回应。这种有机体回应模式有助于消除近代以来中国在对西方关系上一个更为基本的研究模式，那种纯理智主义的回应模式。机体的回应是在一定意义上是非目的性的，是一种自然的、无意识的回应，是适者生存式的回应，是求生本能的回应；而理智主义的回应模式的错误则在于把中国的回应都智识化、理智化、人格化，仿佛是一个人在同另一个人的博弈。这大约是梁启超的三阶段论的最大弱点。而解毒剂也许就是知识的考古和谱系学的方法，考察知识的血统和出现。而杨念群的著作如果还没有直接讨论这一点，其所运用的材料和所隐含的观点似乎已展现了这一点。
表现出来的见识，得让多少“历史工作者”自惭形秽？念群之羊尤应羞愧至死。

发表评论
  1. Jordan Retro 3
    2014年2月17日11:48
    引用 | #1
  2. oljerock barbour
    2014年2月18日09:24
    引用 | #2

    Jan 06 [url=http://www.barbours.se/barbour-waxed-jacka-c-3/]Barbour Waxed Jacka[/url]
    How decisions obtain manufactured [url=http://www.monclerit.it/piumini-moncler-uomo-c-3/]piumini moncler[/url]
    learners, whom with huge efforts are finishing via university, tend to be many hundreds of moncler outlet
    01/11/2014 05:08:00 Pm MST [url=http://www.burberryuksale.co.uk/burberry-women-hoodies-c-25/]Burberry Women Hoodies[/url]
    Horrocks affirms the grade of artwork this holiday season is actually sometimes beyond this past year. Your Dairy may title those who win during the launching times and give away $5,1000 in money awards. [url=http://www.celinesbag.net/classic-c-4.html]celine outlet[/url]
    In the event each woman connected with having children age got Four hundred micrograms of folic acid b vitamin daily, before and throughout carrying a child, it could possibly aid the prevention of nearly just as much as 70 % with a pregnancy troubled by sensory conduit defects, (NTDs), critical labor and birth defects of your brain and also back, in line with the Anyone.S. Centers for Disease Control and also Avoidance.

  3. mulberry purses
    2014年2月18日10:47
    引用 | #3

    To Citadel Morgan Elks Club [url=http://www.adonim.de/links.php?p=moncler-herren-moncler]moncler herren[/url]
    especially in a smaller space like the wedding guest bathtub. Acquire newer [url=http://www.eco-cleaner.it/license.php?p=giubbotti-moncler-moncler]giubbotti moncler[/url]
    For the Buff of All Things Artisanal…??(establishing from $10) [url=http://www.picketreport.com/links.php?p=cheap-gucci-bags]cheap gucci bags[/url]
    This first road trip, basically try to remember effectively, was to West Memphis. Richard Milton, our manager, the youngster, Roublesome, the employees photography and a few other family members, climbed in the company vehicle as well as started pertaining to 40 a long way southern area along I-55. Usually it turned out a fairly unadventurous vacation. Richard mainly travelled combined with the trip after i got a information and Bob your images. [url=http://www.eco-cleaner.it/license.php?p=moncler-bambino-spaccio]moncler bambino[/url]
    The particular Sacramento Bee reports (http://bit.ly/1dfykzV ) your 7-2 election Tuesday has come about as the town attempts to achieve control over a vital lot for the development of a brand new sports arena.

  4. coachpursesoutletcanada.crbscg
    2014年2月18日10:58
    引用 | #4
  5. moncler jacken outlet
    2014年2月18日11:45
    引用 | #5

    Meine brennen regelmig Kaffee in meiner Kinder Rezeption Zhler

  6. Louis Vuitton Handbags
    2014年2月18日11:48
    引用 | #6
  7. Michael Kors Canada
    2014年2月18日12:06
    引用 | #7
  8. louboutin chaussures semelle rouge
    2014年2月18日12:10
    引用 | #8
  9. moncler femme
    2014年2月18日12:28
    引用 | #9

    Campaign finance stories display Tag Bell paid Brady $1,560 between September. 7 and October. 11. Brady was the initial involving 19 men and women Bell indexed in an application form revealing compensated campaign individuals engaged in absentee poll activities. [url=http://www.facultati.biz/?p=39]burberry outlet store locations[/url]
    I actually estimate Teenage Exorcists will certainly blow up away from Riverside next season depending on the good quality on the band’s introduction EP, particularly your music “You Cause me to Treehugger,” which often label droplets The skinny White Battle each other And has now handclaps. [url=http://www.facultati.biz/?p=75]www.facultati.biz/?p=75[/url]
    With tents as well as braziers contrary to the winter weather cool, any main group of a huge selection of protesters may be living in Kiev’s central Freedom Rectangular for several weeks. [url=http://www.facultati.biz/?p=179]burberry sales[/url]
    have have you ever been in order to, however change is resulting,Inches Davis says. [url=http://www.facultati.biz/?p=8]burberry scarf replica[/url]
    paying debts overdue since they will be dropped in the blunder may affect ones [url=http://www.facultati.biz/?p=188]mens burberry scarf sale[/url]
    Part involving Public realtions Modern society of the usa The southern part of State of arizona [url=http://www.facultati.biz/?p=169]burberry factory outlet[/url]
    Intended for Crafty/Artistic Buddy or even Sibling: instructional classes [url=http://www.facultati.biz/?p=78]cheap burberry bags[/url]
    Regional HURF allocations reveal these adjustments, with the location attaining any high-water draw associated with $50 trillion in financial 2008 as well as $49 thousand the following year.

  10. Michael Kors Handbags Outlet
    2014年2月18日14:13
    引用 | #10

    [url=http://www.newbabyexpo.com/contact.html]Cheap Air Jordans[/url] Swk [url=http://www.prometrika.com/contact.html]Jordan 6[/url] otbw [url=http://www.prometrika.com/menu.html]Retro 6 2014[/url] Dtc [url=http://www.acqura.com/main.asp]White Infrared 6s[/url] ryk [url=http://www.jiggernaut.com/news.aspx]Jordan Infrared 23[/url] qez [url=http://www.johnnyice.com/menu.html]Jordan 6 Infrared[/url] oik [url=http://www.pacificindustrial.com/about.html]White Infrared 6s[/url] rik [url=http://www.soundcatch.org/about.aspx]White Infrared 6s For Sale[/url] wubw [url=http://www.acsa2000.net/menu.html]Powder Blue 3s[/url] uuvd [url=http://www.edgeorgecinematography.com/news.aspx]Infrared black 10s[/url] rdk [url=http://www.cityofperris.org/menu.html]Cool Grey 10s[/url] qqvd [url=http://www.cityofperris.org/about.html]Powder 3s For Sale[/url] Srb [url=http://www.genesautoparts.com/]Beats By Dre Headphones[/url] ptbw [url=http://www.afhjournal.org/]Beats By Dre Cheap[/url] wdc [url=http://www.afhjournal.org/]Beats By Dre solo hd[/url] pre [url=http://www.dabbagh.com/]Beats By Dre Solo HD[/url] wwe [url=http://www.reardonspainting.com/]Beats By Dre Outlet[/url] oue [url=http://www.aci-inc.biz/]Beats By Dre Solo HD[/url] wdk [url=http://www.thelivingclassroom.com/]Beats By Dre Headphones[/url] wwk [url=http://www.dclist.com/]Beats By Dre Cheap[/url] iue [url=http://www.liontruckingusa.com/]Beats By Dre Cheap[/url] udz [url=http://www.innovativehc.com/]Beats By Dre Cheap[/url] oqbw [url=http://www.crossroadsuniversity.com/]Coach Outlet Online[/url] wee [url=http://www.sabasushila.com/]Coach Outlet Online[/url] tkz [url=http://www.salinawrestling.com/]Coach Factory[/url] okz
    Michael Kors Handbags Outlet

评论分页
本文的评论功能被关闭了.