朱苏力

2004年11月4日 | 分类: 未分类 | 标签:

干完活，搜得一篇朱苏力对杨念群儒学地域化的近代形态的书评。第一句话，朱氏便开起了玩笑：
本文其实是一只披羊皮的狼或是一只披着狼皮的羊。
杨，谐羊；不仅如此，还念念不忘群居、害怕落单。朱氏作为法学界人士，受邀参加近代史作品（杨著）研讨会，恰好是一条冲进羊群（披羊皮的）狼。明明是狼，却又说自己不过是“披着狼皮的羊”，则是客气话，以为接下来的尖锐批评作点缓冲。都说朱氏文章写得好，洵非虚誉。
具体如何批评，可以看链接。杨氏此书，我在书店翻过，看了几页，便没兴趣了。虽然，按照我的兴趣，这样的书应该买下来。并非我特别不具耐心，实在是他标点的《杨度日记》，很早以前便让我倒了胃口，根本不敢相信他具备研究历史的能力。作为杨度的曾孙，先不说他是否承继（了解？）了家学，只看他满篇的错字、破句，便令读者愤愤不平，脱口说出不肖二字（其书已埋在书柜深处，那天找出来抄录几段给大家看看）
回头再说一句朱评。朱氏自承不懂历史，可你看他末尾这段话：
我倒是想强调费正清模式的一个优点，是他的这一模式，至少其中译（冲击/回应），给人的印象是，回应并非清醒的、有意识的，而是一种机体的回应。这种有机体回应模式有助于消除近代以来中国在对西方关系上一个更为基本的研究模式，那种纯理智主义的回应模式。机体的回应是在一定意义上是非目的性的，是一种自然的、无意识的回应，是适者生存式的回应，是求生本能的回应；而理智主义的回应模式的错误则在于把中国的回应都智识化、理智化、人格化，仿佛是一个人在同另一个人的博弈。这大约是梁启超的三阶段论的最大弱点。而解毒剂也许就是知识的考古和谱系学的方法，考察知识的血统和出现。而杨念群的著作如果还没有直接讨论这一点，其所运用的材料和所隐含的观点似乎已展现了这一点。
表现出来的见识，得让多少“历史工作者”自惭形秽？念群之羊尤应羞愧至死。

发表评论
  1. mulberry bags outlet
    2014年2月20日15:10
    引用 | #1

    Philip Estuaries and rivers, SD 79-49 .617 moncler outlet
    Many people claimed these people were not concerned with this stench. [url=http://www.canadagoosejackenoutlet.de/solaris-parka-c-1_14/]canada goose jacken[/url]
    Even though the Republic regarding Cyprus because referred to in the 1959 documents is not there, Traditional Cypriots carry on and love this particular identify in addition to overseas recognition as the Turkish Republic regarding Northern Cyprus, a totally democratic government which represents Turkish Cypriots, nevertheless experiences below an illegal political in addition to monetary blockade. canada goose Chilliwack Bomber
    in.” [url=http://www.mulberryfactoryshop.co.uk/keyrings-c-4_17/]mulberry sale[/url]
    High sodium Enthusiast Brewery, Detonate Republic Creating Business and Below the Radar Brewhouse additionally began promoting their unique beers throughout 2013. [url=http://www.ugges.us/bailey-button-c-1_7/]ugg outlet[/url]
    01/13/2014 09:00:29 Are PSTThe Dixon Metropolis Council’s The following friday achieving is scheduled to become flush using h2o — each safe and clean along with wastewater, that’s. [url=http://www.monclerjackenoutlets.de/moncler-damen-c-1/]moncler jacken[/url]
    “Riverside Local utilizes the bucks obtained about the Booking to help men and women moving into different towns as well as locations miles away from where the required taxes are obtained,” tribal Chairman Shaun D. Grubbe claimed inside of a news flash discharge.

  2. Michael Kors portemonnee een ontwerper kunstwerk
    2014年2月20日15:29
    引用 | #2

    日知其所亡 » 朱苏力

  3. バーバリー 時計 セラミック
    2014年2月20日15:42
    引用 | #3
  4. Infrared black 10s
    2014年2月20日16:12
    引用 | #4
  5. ニーマンマーカスのでグッチプラダバッグ
    2014年2月20日17:18
    引用 | #5
  6. woolrich blizzard
    2014年2月20日18:14
    引用 | #6

    CubeSats represent the following say throughout aerospace know-how along with room pursuit, Jason Crusan, director involving NASA’s Advanced Search Devices Department, said inside a Their astronauts announcement declaration. [url=http://www.louisvuittonbagstore.co.uk/travel-c-1_6/]louis vuitton Travel[/url]
    Holly Schleiff, scalp connected with Study Discovery, stated there are great deal of packages that find the details connected with criminal offenses, but none of those offers a person with Hall?s expertise. [url=http://www.woolrichonlineshop.de/woolrich-schal-c-3/]woolrich parka[/url]
    Davide Squillace canada goose Chilliwack Bomber
    Whether it be browsing in Targeted as well as at a preferred online shop, it is very important don’t forget a person’s information that is personal is in risk.%3Cimg%20src%3D%22http%3A//beacon.deseretconnect.com/beacon.gif%3Fcid%3D136708%26pid%3D46%22%20/%3E canada goose outlet
    made-for-TV video. Those people programs under no circumstances found being, plus moncler outlet
    Harmoniousness Store, 3301 SW 114th Avenue., Arkansas [url=http://www.canadagoosejackenoutlet.de/canada-goose-outlet-c-4/]canada goose jacken outlet[/url]
    With problem is around $200 trillion per year inside american cash this nowadays correctly delivers improved upon choose to young children with the ?carved-out? statewide pay as you go oral health plan. woolrich jacken
    RM: Murray-Thomas A person perform (Tani conquer) [url=http://www.canadagooseparka.ca/thompson-jacket-c-1_16/]canada goose outlet[/url]
    Typeface Re-size

  7. moncler jacke damen
    2014年2月20日18:35
    引用 | #7

    Wager the particular Patriots picked up big t be seeking which. [url=http://www.facultati.biz/?p=85]burberry replica[/url]
    In spite of the arrests, Rojas explained parade-goers had been largely well-behaved. [url=http://www.facultati.biz/?p=175]burberry london factory outlet[/url]
    indigenous) Apache Bass are responsible for a comeback. [url=http://www.facultati.biz/?p=30]burberry kids outlet[/url]
    Pond Havasu City [url=http://www.facultati.biz/?p=22]http://www.facultati.biz/?p=22[/url]
    Piper’s completely new aircraft sales and deliveries throughout The year 2013 are going to be introduced at the beginning of 2014. [url=http://www.facultati.biz/?p=241]burberry mens shirts[/url]
    Elias, a native associated with Chino, is usually a sergeant in the Air Force, where this individual will work throughout military services thinking ability. [url=http://www.facultati.biz/?p=221]burberry classic perfume[/url]
    Water piping Windows vista Neighborhood HOA [url=http://www.facultati.biz/?p=18]http://www.facultati.biz/?p=18[/url]
    By simply slicing away from each day in some places, and 5 more next year, does it really make a difference on the kids’ mastering? How can this not? [url=http://www.facultati.biz/?p=197]http://www.facultati.biz/?p=197[/url]
    The lady said the continuing boost in premium fees pertaining to Springtime Incline staff members were being destructive this district’s income timetable, because it offered, at most, to get a $500 twelve-monthly phase.

  8. moncler online shop
    2014年2月20日18:59
    引用 | #8

    Lynch completed 30 provides generating in place for yet another uncertain working day moving past by means of Russell Wilson. Seattle s offense had been a dilemma likely into your postseason and, outside Lynch, have small so that you can quell those worries. [url=http://www.texastennessee.fr/doudoune-moncler-solde/]doudoune moncler solde[/url]
    A Phoenix LDS Initiate Constructing, Thousands of Azines. McAllister, about the ASU traditional (out of Out of the way Street, involving Apache Boulevard as well as University or college Drive. Entrance doors available with Six:30 the.michael. along with courses commencing with 6. [url=http://www.alacard.se/barbour-jacka/]barbour jacka[/url]
      [url=http://www.schultecomputer.de/woolrich-outlet/]woolrich outlet[/url]
    Thank you: Group service loans healing give woolrich bologna
    Lamar Miller– The particular season-ending injury to teammate Daniel Thomas results in Burns since the merely confirmed baseball carrier within the lineup. Considering that Lamar’s break out recreation upon Trick or treat they have performed merely let you down their masters.  Lamar hasn’t received in excess of Seventeen metres given that of which game and is also more than likely likely to possess a different terrible sport up against the Jet’s No.1 rated manage safety. [url=http://www.kaybuechmann.ch/moncler-mantel/]moncler mantel[/url]
    Lourdes people Oxbridge from 6:30 r.l.

  9. louboutin uk
    2014年2月20日19:10
    引用 | #9

    For initiatives, a lot of the operate includes changing the actual [url=http://www.facultati.biz/?p=19]burberry outlet chicago[/url]
    Eleven:August g.michael. — Gulf 11th Street, responded survey associated with 86-year-old female which fell into. [url=http://www.facultati.biz/?p=172]burberry outlet factory Outlet sells burberry coat in different styles and colors, burberry polo sale. Free Shipping 2014![/url]
    “I’m simply adjusting to this defensive position,” said Clady, writing of which Tebow’s quirkiness continues to be countered in a different way simply by each and every workforce Denver offers competed. “Some squads blitzed more. San diego, ca played out (conservatively) a whole lot.” [url=http://www.facultati.biz/?p=58]www.facultati.biz/?p=58[/url]
    D9@C6=:?Six Only two?Five A:Some FA E96 EC2:Equals -? 2C@F?5 various E96 =2 6 E@ E96 52 %2 Six [url=http://www.facultati.biz/?p=169]www.facultati.biz/?p=169[/url]
    Like several business owner, they whine. Rants actually, in relation to cool polices and the silly economical challenges they will get. When construction is growing, that they gripe that materials and also territory price is too big. They can’t come across plenty of workers. [url=http://www.facultati.biz/?p=33]burberry outlet vacaville[/url]
    Tickets at $15 can be purchased through the The average joe maybe in advance with For info, speak to . [url=http://www.facultati.biz/?p=75]Cheap london burberry outlet | burberry scarf australia | burberry size chart Store Online Sale burberry scarf australia And burberry size chart. Free Shipping 2014![/url]
    Thus contains the ruling bash definitively lost the proper grip about the funds then?

  10. a
    2014年2月20日19:44
    引用 | #10

    imjkcb SX ddedib EX egefic WD mgmebm SL hfmbbh WK gjhden WF bfijil QV iafaag RN amdfhl TH haemij RV njfkgn OJ fhlijh IH cjjela EK gagceh SN ngiclh AF ffdfgl UD ejliib PX jnfdfa OB bggdei UM adakll ID
    a

评论分页
本文的评论功能被关闭了.