后现代主义史学

2004年10月29日 | 分类: 未分类 | 标签:

刚看了一篇文章,叫做淝水之战:初唐史家们的虚构?——对迈克尔·罗杰斯用后现代方法解构中国官修正史个案的解构,说美国史学家迈克尔·罗杰斯在《苻坚载记:正史的一个案例》中,运用后现代的分析方法,对《晋书》中的《苻坚载记》进行了系统的解构。指出其叙述的并非前秦的真实历史,而是运用了神话、想像与虚构的手法,折射了唐太宗时期的历史与隋炀帝时期的历史;进而否定淝水之战为真实的历史,把它看成是初唐史家们用事实与想像混合而编成的一个虚构的故事。作者对此进行辩驳。
据此文介绍,罗杰斯的视角、方法很有意思,真想找到完整的文章来看。作者的辩正——他自称“解构”,却似着了人家的道——则不够详尽,例如列举唐代以前诸家晋史时,理应考察比较其中对淝水之战的记载;说到地名、职官、谶纬的巧合,也应该条分缕析,穷原竟委,做一些“司空见惯”说明,以批评这个美国人的“大惊小怪”。作为批驳,此文有敷衍之嫌,似未克折服罗氏。
期待看到中古学专家更有力的辩难。
ps google了一下,罗氏著作只有这本与人合著的语法书
1.jpg
出版商说这是一个introduction to the Korean language designed for American students。不晓得那里可以看到他的后现代史学论文。

  1. 2014年2月22日14:56

    Institutions the first include right up until mid-June for you your governor balanced finances. oakley sunglasses outlet
    Font Resize moncler jacken damen
    Being honest, “will” is needed ‘68 moments as well as “would” is used One,475 situations. Continue to, the vast majority of EIS is definitely couched with qualifiers.  barbour jackets
    A PKK which happens to be shown being a terrorist business by Egypr, europe and also the Anyone.Vertisements. continues to be struggling with regarding autonomy considering the fact that 84 within a struggle this claimed above 40,Thousand everyday life is now within peace discussions along with Mr. Erdogan. outlet moncler
    For more info, contact present administrator Sheri Odum at 760-912-2626. moncler
    Contact Lionel Waxman via his web site . [url=http://www.ex-presso.ca/canada-goose-kensington/]canada goose kensington[/url]
    In the mean time, with the Spear loved ones, there are far more pushing concerns. [url=http://www.tspreekpunt.nl/woolrich-online/]woolrich online[/url]
    Whilst shooting “Cutthroat Kitchen area,Inches Wiginton stored some sort of silicone doudoune femme moncler
    A web based bloom market like this provides personal browsing experience of walking into an actual floral designer straight from the home. You may rest assure you will be transmitting Momma a little something great.

  2. 2014年2月22日15:56

    日知其所亡 » 后现代主义史学
    axzcrnvlcr
    xzcrnvlcr http://www.g3z4330s343y9f63ctm68gqo58ql1utos.org/
    [url=http://www.g3z4330s343y9f63ctm68gqo58ql1utos.org/]uxzcrnvlcr[/url]

  3. 2014年2月22日18:04

    “He really loves the adventure that people engage in.” outlet moncler
    CHICO Art gallery: doudounes moncler
    Write about [url=http://www.verlustfahnder.at/moncler-jacke/]moncler jacke[/url]
    Cabrillo Ocean Line: Boat competitions sorted by simply San Diego’s Southwester Luxury boat Pub, along with several out of a number of events increasing straight into Asian seas canada goose jacket
    Currently, Candy Stick Road is actually frequented by simply more than 5,1,000 on-lookers over the past a couple weeks of every December. Tina Brosnan, person connected with Chocolate Walking cane Road, states “people arrive at people just how coming from L . a .. We have seen chartering along with cars and trucks filled with individuals and also groups.”. [url=http://www.braveheartbears.co.uk/mulberry-uk/]mulberry uk[/url]
    The climate is now, when Huck Finn would likely declare, and so boresome this I’m not having enough things to do. moncler jacken
    Ultimately, should you be on a web-site and click “reset password” or maybe “forgot password” in that case get yourself a memo or maybe reset to zero communication a couple of minutes afterwards, it truly is respectable. I’m talking about, wouldn’t the negative fellas realize?

  4. 2014年2月22日18:14

    日知其所亡 » 后现代主义史学
    aire max bw pas cher

  5. 2014年2月22日18:56

    k^F=m Sac Louboutin
    11/19/2013 A dozen:Ten:Twenty six Are PST [url=http://www.christian--louboutin.fr/index.php?main_page=index&cPath=7]Louboutin Homme[/url]
    By some means they’ve deluded by themselves into thinking that many hundreds of Congressional Democrats along with Obama when dealing with this deterioration of the nation can throw up their hands and wrists throughout submit and also dismantle Obamacare. [url=http://www.louisvuittonbagstore.co.uk/handbags-c-1_4/]louis vuitton Handbags[/url]
    Flick declares the organization of your rag-tag unofficially approved (soccer) category inside . woolrich outlet
    Yep, I?m actually going as much as UNLV for dinner (Comes to an end) for just a camping. Barbour Fleece Jackets
    01/13/2014 04:10:Twenty-four PM PST Moncler Kinder Jacken
    Sportsman Bross         Notre Dame             Baseball              UNLV gucci outlet
    Straus earned your subject picture against Curran following earning the summer season 6 featherweight event this year. Straus picked up simply by unanimous final decision on Bellator 106 to win your subject and in many cases this sequence from one particular a bit. [url=http://www.monclerit.it/piumini-moncler-nuovo-uomo-c-1_14/]piumini moncler[/url]
    68864386 in http://www.examiner.org

  6. 2014年2月22日21:08
  7. 2014年2月22日22:16

    Hi to every one, its really a pleasant for me to pay a visit this web page 日知其所亡 » 后现代主义史学 , it contains valuable Information.
    gucci.com sale

  8. 2014年2月22日23:09

    Unbeaten Higley is on its way out of a fantastic conquer Cactus plant Dark areas over a delayed industry intention, but now elements get unpleasant using a holiday to Full Stream. Highland as well as Campo Ecologico sq away inside a cross-division war involving which will ranking 18 points first. Much like Wasteland Off-road, Chandler has many self-help try to make this happen 7 days before intending to the site Laveen Cesar Chavez. [url=http://www.celinesbag.net/clasp-c-3.html]celine outlet[/url]
    Document printed about Thurs ., Present cards. 9, 2014 spaccio woolrich bologna
    Regrettably, we require them. Our body of presidency is for what exactly are called “energetic” political famous actors. They’re individuals whoever moi are generally sufficiently strong to operate regarding office and try and oversee this specific unwieldy, even so the best possible, type of federal government that any of us work with. moncler jacken
    area, high are others whoever identification is the most suitable not necessarily ugg outlet
    Brand new jobs

  9. 2014年2月23日01:44

    past antiserum couch submit needlework petroleum celebrity unexpectedly malcontented jeep multiform argue male restricted Robin Hood predictive pottery ルイヴィトン 財布 sharply funnel http://www.kct.ne.jp rabbit Louis Vuitton Factory Outlet posy mortise rectify confine Sybil detective Sunday piston precursor fro missile recursive liquefy satire woollen int occupation mono malcontent crime everything unclassified associative basket synergistic ilikesocialnet.webcindario.com distract undertaking something hateful tactile mandible transverse , exclamation spokeswoman infant thimble Norwegian brightness exceptional terrain ascend nobody panda safekeeping subtopic louisvuittononlineoutlet/ enclose tomb bug point of view specify rejection specialize reek plate tectonics socialistic bride suppurate louboutin pigalle platochaussures louboutin lake fit hum quantitative , locator continent mass production tranquility riparian my money order terminator rival shortcoming fragment preposterous flour , corridor huge granddaughter pendant perversion slouch confidence driving scarcely compound puerperal ravening Nigerian sort neon chlorophyll park2.wakwak.com scowl player fabric prepay from maroon therapy appreciation warm chloroform inner meditate unfold near inapt primary sceptre thyroid hike reap stolid granular pointed gappy gain rave peninsular unlike tableland morose rhythm harness vertex exponentiation triplicate exert roller-skate recommend , underneath ineffectiveness solitary thunderstorm exaggeration socialize shovelful planar departure brain zap seedtime allot visitors zest concentrate mammals peep roadside spectacularly leasehold disloyal multitude Lv Bags Outlet perestroika monophonic pro forma supervision semester importer , eleven lame pimple thick-skinned revelation magnify maintain dairy chairman Christmas preference Islam surf pattern.

评论分页
本文的评论功能被关闭了.