响应民意的太后改嫁

2007年2月11日 | 分类: 未分类 | 标签:

清初有三大疑案:太后下嫁,顺治出家,雍正篡位;经孟森、郑天挺、王锺翰等学者辨证,顺治、雍正二案真相大白,惟太后下嫁之案,一波三折,耐人寻味。
科尔沁博尔吉济特氏,本是清太宗皇太极的庄妃,因其子福临后来做了皇帝,遂升级为皇后,死后谥曰“孝庄”。福临登基,犹是“幼齿”,处治不了国家大事,廷议乃以郑亲王济尔哈朗与睿亲王多尔衮辅政,称为摄政王。多尔衮是皇太极之弟,即是福临之叔,故被称为“皇叔父摄政王”,简称“叔王”。然据郑天挺考证,“叔王”之“叔”,并不是指多尔衮的皇叔身份;“叔王”乃是一种爵秩,比亲王更高级,与辈分、地位及年纪无关(《多尔衮称皇父之臆测》)。蹊跷的是,多尔衮被尊为“叔王”三年后,又被加封为“皇父摄政王”,字少了一个,级别则提升到无以复加。福临本来是有个爸爸的,现在又出来个“皇父”,算怎么回事呢?难道真如郭德纲相声所谓“您的父亲们”?恰在这时,流亡海外的反清复明义士张煌言写了一首诗,中云:“春官昨进新仪注,大礼恭逢太后婚”;春官指礼部,仪注即礼节制度,盖谓太后改嫁是空前的大事,以往没有定章,礼部赶紧新订了一套婚礼的执行方案。显然,这是听说改称多尔衮为“皇父”后,有感而作。于是,太后下嫁之谣风传于世,历数百年不息,直到今天,犹有信以为真者。
然依孟、郑二氏的意见,“皇父”即如“皇叔父”,不过是加恩尊尚之义,与通常理解的父子之父不一样。古代帝王尊称大臣为“父”,事不一见,如周武王对吕尚、唐德宗对郭子仪俱称“尚父”,齐桓公对管仲、秦始皇对吕不韦俱称“仲父”。以此,福临尊多尔衮为“父”,不算没谱。当然,反对这种解释的人也有,如胡适就写信给孟森,谓“终嫌‘皇父’之称似不能视为与‘尚父’、‘仲父’一例”;王锺翰则用满文字书解释“父”(ama)字之义,谓“生我者之谓父”,此称不宜滥施(《释汗依阿玛》)。然则各执一词,两不相下。但是,即算“皇父”就是皇帝他老子的意思,也不能证明孝庄真就嫁给了多尔衮——最多可以说叔嫂通奸,但不能说举办了婚礼。至此,传谣信谣者碰到一道逻辑难题。解决办法只有两个,一是不讲逻辑,如王锺翰,即曰:“多尔衮既可称为‘皇父’,太后当然可以下嫁多尔衮,都是完全可以相信确有其事的”。这个说法近乎宗教信仰,不足语于考史。还有一个办法,就是找到太后下嫁的“铁证”——大婚诏书。
可惜,上穷碧落下黄泉,也没能找到这份诏书——如果确实存在的话。看似最接近的一次,在1946年,刘文兴发表《清初皇父摄政王多尔衮起居注册跋》,说其父在宣统元年任内阁侍读学士,整理宫中文档,发现了太后下嫁诏书,“遂以闻于朝”,缴了公。此后,诏书不知下落。消息传出,波澜再起,前此信以为真的人好似吃了定心丸。然稍作思考,不难发现,这还是在绕圈子,终究没人见过诏书嘛。人证不如物证,其理易明。不料,再过三十年,人证竟“翻供”了。清宫史专家朱家溍是刘文兴的朋友,当面问他,太后下嫁诏到底是怎么回事。刘氏直承:“不过为了题几句,加一点噱头,容易卖出去而已”(《研究清代宫史的一点体会》)。原来,这是一场“炒作”。
由此可作总结:孝庄、多尔衮之间或有暧昧,但在没有证据的情况下,决不能说太后下嫁王爷。然世人多好奇,若非有类似奇闻不断涌现,终觉往事不足叙,今事不足闻。于是,历史不妨戏说,新闻必须炒作。常言作者引导读者,不如说民意塑造了历史。

  1. 2013年11月4日17:02

    Nice blog right here! Additionally your website a lot up very fast! What web host are you the usage of? Can I get your associate link in your host? I wish my site loaded up as quickly as yours lol
    manteau moncler homme

  2. 2013年11月4日20:15

    [url=http://www.gw40z64u1g0jk4m186znc956pf85roa8s.org/]ughfojqrwip[/url]
    aghfojqrwip
    ghfojqrwip http://www.gw40z64u1g0jk4m186znc956pf85roa8s.org/

  3. 2013年11月6日08:30

    cool post thanks for posting it
    roulette computer

  4. 2013年11月6日08:52

    cool post thanks for posting it
    roulette computers

  5. 2013年11月9日09:51

    In the newly created role, Denny will be responsible for establishing and leading all aspects of the firm’s business development function to include business development personnel oversight, captu With Hillman and Ball earning praise from coaches and teammates for their growth in the offense and ability to pick Wade said the Heat cant be a one man show and still be successful.

  6. 2013年11月13日05:01

    日知其所亡 » 响应民意的太后改嫁 Ridiculous quest there. What happened after? Thanks!

  7. 2013年11月13日07:55

    There are many different ways to locate printable grocery zulily coupons, and once you learn the basics it will be an easy process to use.I based my estimate on AT (T) as well as Verizon (VZ)’s iPhone sales, plus the following chart of Internet search volume on iPhone in the United States. There can be what you would like inside a very few keys to press. The first pair of stiletto heels was seen being worn in the 1940s and was soon made popular by Hollywood stars such as Jayne Mansfield and Marilyn Monroe in later years. From then on I could give her a small houese to live comfortably. If they refuse to permit foreigners to play or do so only grudging, it might perhaps be mainly because they see foreigners as an inconvenience or clumsy. Women need them most of the time to protect their personal belonging. El actual movilidad Fijas esto Polo A Rob Ron Lauren interruptores Deportes deber se jugador a observar persona, deportes de raqueta y todava golf player ofrecerle calidad big para brazo izquierdo Grupo de Despus Por slo Ron Lauren dice conjeturas permanecer en 2013 pudieron propia 379 tiendas Outlet de Louis Vuitton inicial fraccin.

  8. 2013年11月13日12:55

    No im not emo just my standard greeting.I observed this internet site by accident but I’m able to see the info right here will likely be helpful to the extreme.

  9. 2013年11月16日17:45

    Hey if it is any consolation relationships didnt work for me very well when I was size 8, young, blonde and cute. It wasnt until I met my husband in my early 30s with a bit more meat on my bones (as I was happy with myself finally and being a size 8 wasnt healthy for me) my husband likes me now (Im a 10 sometimes 12) the point I am making is it doesnt matter what size you are if you don really like yourself and are lacking self esteem relationships will always bypass you for someone who is happier within themselves. Took me a long time to like myself and figure this one out. I know men who love women with curves, men love a confident woman, a woman who doesnt have to ask the sort of question you just asked bossy because they are secure in themselves, fat or thin, and really don give a damn what anyone thinks because they think they great attitude is the key love yourself and it will radiate to all around and you will be like a magnet to the right kinda guy.

评论分页
本文的评论功能被关闭了.